Elite Automotive Finishes makeitelite.com/
they are in Mesa at Alma School and Broadway.
Owner operated shop, friends of Caroline and I. They do everything from minor dings to full custom builds on true exotics. Their work is impeccable but it also isn't cheap. They do work with all the insurance companies so maybe they can help with getting the claim covered.
Chris Soehren is the owner, sometimes takes him a day do reply, he works alongside his crew as well as being the boss.
They handled a nasty gouge someone put on the FJ when it was only a few weeks old. I have never been able to tell where the dammage was because it was fixed properly.